How AI and Politics Stalled the Open-Source Security Movement

Want latest news insights in your inbox? Sign up for our weekly newsletters to get only what matters to your organization. Subscribe Now

 

In November 2021, the discovery of Log4Shell — a zero-day vulnerability in the widely used Log4j Java logging library — sent shockwaves through the technology industry. The incident was a wake-up call, exposing just how dependent our global infrastructure is on open-source software — and how fragile that ecosystem can be.

The response was swift: the White House hosted a summit, tech giants pledged millions of dollars, and the Linux Foundation’s Open Source Security Foundation (OpenSSF) launched tools and initiatives to protect the code that powers the internet. But nearly four years later, the momentum has slowed.

A Promising Start

In the months after Log4Shell, there was unprecedented collaboration between the public and private sectors.

  • OpenSSF’s Sigstore project allowed developers to digitally sign code to prevent tampering.

  • Repositories were hardened to ensure developers inherited better security practices.

  • Memory-safe programming languages like Rust gained adoption for cryptographic libraries.

  • CISA served as a bridge between federal agencies and open-source maintainers, improving incident response coordination.

This surge of attention helped prevent incidents like the 2024 XZ Utils crisis from becoming even worse.

Where Progress Slowed

Despite these gains, several forces have stalled the movement:

  • Shift to AI: The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked a turning point. Companies began reallocating their developers, security experts, and legal staff from open-source security work to AI initiatives.

  • Political Transition: Government momentum slowed after political changes in Washington. Experts like Jack Cable and Aeva Black, who once championed open-source security within CISA, departed, leaving a gap in leadership.

  • Unmet Promises: Many tech companies did not fulfill the financial and personnel pledges they made in 2021, leaving the community frustrated.

As a result, investment has dropped, and critical open-source projects remain understaffed and underfunded.

Where Progress Slowed

Despite these gains, several forces have stalled the movement:

  • Shift to AI: The release of ChatGPT in late 2022 marked a turning point. Companies began reallocating their developers, security experts, and legal staff from open-source security work to AI initiatives.

  • Political Transition: Government momentum slowed after political changes in Washington. Experts like Jack Cable and Aeva Black, who once championed open-source security within CISA, departed, leaving a gap in leadership.

  • Unmet Promises: Many tech companies did not fulfill the financial and personnel pledges they made in 2021, leaving the community frustrated.

As a result, investment has dropped, and critical open-source projects remain understaffed and underfunded.

The Risks Ahead

Open-source software is everywhere — from military systems to home IoT devices — yet many organizations still lack visibility into where their code comes from. Outdated and vulnerable versions of Log4j still account for 13% of all downloads, years after the fix was released.

Meanwhile, maintainers of essential packages are increasingly overwhelmed, sometimes fending off poorly written AI-generated patches that create more work than they solve.

Why Renewed Action Matters

Experts warn that if industry and government don’t double down, the next Log4Shell-level vulnerability could have far worse consequences.

  • SBOMs (Software Bills of Materials) and tools like OpenSSF’s Scorecard can give developers better visibility into dependencies.

  • Memory-safe rewrites of critical packages can prevent entire classes of vulnerabilities.

  • Direct investment in under-maintained but essential projects is crucial to reducing risk.

As David Nalley of AWS puts it, “Investing in the plumbing is really important.”

A Call to Refocus

The open-source community has shown what is possible when the world comes together to secure the foundations of modern computing. But we cannot afford to lose the momentum that Log4Shell created. AI and politics may have distracted us, but the risk hasn’t gone away — it’s only grown.

Now is the time for industry, government, and developers to recommit to securing the software supply chain before the next crisis forces us to act.

📬 Want to stay ahead of emerging cybersecurity challenges like this?
Subscribe to our newsletter for weekly insights, updates, and expert analysis.